Share for friends:

A Philosophical Investigation (2010)

A Philosophical Investigation (2010)

Book Info

Author
Genre
Rating
3.6 of 5 Votes: 1
Your rating
ISBN
0452271401 (ISBN13: 9780452271401)
Language
English
Publisher
penguin books

About book A Philosophical Investigation (2010)

Quite a refreshing read. This author is not afraid to try new things and changes around the trappings of the long established detective genre, with mixed results. We follow Jake, a protagonist we can freely call a militant lesbian since the author himself does exactly that. To my great relief this strong characterization doesn't get in the way of the plot or the story and shouldn't make anyone uncomfortable, in fact there are so many other politically incorrect situations described correctly that at some point the extreme descriptions feel quite natural and appropriate.Police Detective Jake manages to place herself at the head of an investigation into the search for a serial killer who hunts other potential killers. Written in 1992 the novel postulates what society and criminal investigation might look like in our current age. Some is spot on some not so much. Both Jake and the killer use criminal profiling in their cat and mouse game but the core method of investigation is, or should have been, philosophy. The killer is obsessed with his idol the philosopher Wittgenstein and kills other killers who's assigned nickname by the criminal database also correspond to philosophers.What should have been a battle of wits turns instead out to be a battle of wills. The author is so focused on trying to fit philosophy work in the context of crime that the entire endeavor feels forced to say the least. There is much to be enjoyed in this book and I would recommend anyone to read this if only to see the bravado of the author in breaking stereo types and trying out near future predictions. Describing this as a book thought of by Neal Stephenson and executed by William Gibson without directions doesn't feel far from the mark. If there are any gaping plot holes it would have to be things you would think the author knew something about. For example:Schizophrenia is not the same as Multiple Personality Disorder (MPD).A sociopath is not someone who suffers from schizophrenia.There are also incredibly clumsy plot holes that have nothing to do with the technical details of mental illness or philosophy. Quite early on in the novel the police bureau comes up with a good description of the killer and even has a police sketch of his face. As a final touch Jake has an elaborate recording of the killer's voice. However Jake does not instantly recognize the killer after coming in close contact and even speaking with him.

I"ve heard this book refered to for some time as "brilliant" and while there is much to admire about it I just could never get to the point where I could say that I was enjoying the experience of reading it. For the me the main problem can be boiled downt o the fact that the protagonist,a detective for Scotland Yard named Isadora "Jake" Jacowicz hates all men and never tires of talking and thinking about said fact. I've never had much luck getting into novels where the protagonist leaves me cold and "Jake" sure managed to do that. Kerr does do a fine job of weaving psychology and philosophy seemlessly into his story and for that I credit him. He does,however,miss on occasion with his future prognostications. He wrote the novel in 1992 but set it in 2013,now just a scant two years away. I've always believed that if you're going to write about the future you should set it far enough ahead that your work wont date itself too quickly. If you predict a future and people see that you got it wrong your novel(or TV show or movie for that matter) faces the prospect of being labeled as quaint. Not something most writers aspire to. To sum up the novel was exceptional in places,but was hurt past recovery for me by the attitudes and actions of the central character. Probably a better read for a woman or a man less apt than I to be offended by being told page after page that the members of his sex are nothing but disgusting pigs and predators.

Do You like book A Philosophical Investigation (2010)?

Mi videoreseña para este libro: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=frKy7...Un libro muy entretenido de "atrapa al psicópata" que mezcla una narración de thriller, digamos, ordinaria, con filosofía, lo cual le da frescura y originalidad. Philip Kerr para ello utiliza la narración en tercera persona centrada en Jake, la inspectora experta en crímenes contra mujeres que investiga el caso, y una narración en primera persona del asesino, que lleva el nombre clave de Wittgenstein, al escribir sus pensamientos en un diario.Que la historia transcurra en 2013, que en la epoca en la que se escribió el libro (los 90) era el futuro, le daba un aire distópico. Esa fecha ya es pasado para nosotros, así que ese impacto queda disminuido y convertido en curiosidad por saber qué acerto y en qué se equivocó el autor al plantear ese futuro. Pero eso no es culpa del escritor, si no de leerlo en 2014.En resumen, un thriller entretenido y fácil de leer, que aunque plantee retos filosóficos, en ningún momento se torna demasiado pesado o esotérico para seguir la persecución policial.
—Libros Prestados

If you want to read the inner monologue of a serial killer trying to ape Wittgenstein's style, then this is the book for you. I would have enjoyed it more if every single one of those chapters had been cut. Also if the portrayal of the female detective had been handled better (is it really necessary for the killer to create and rape a virtual simulation of her when he is not a sexually motivated killer? Is it really necessary for her to feel a bizarre and uncharacteristic attraction to him? Yuck.)
—Audrey

As we rapidly approach the year 2011 it will soon be twenty years since I read this philosophical crime novel and the time in which it was, if only fictionally, set. The novel was recommended to me by an instructor in the Basic Program of Liberal Studies in which I remain a regular student to this day. But on the side I read novels by contemporary authors and Philip Kerr was a welcome discovery. I especially enjoy his thoughtful style with discussion of ideas: certainly appropriate for a book with philosophical in the title. It is both a book and an author to which I may return as I have enjoyed his subsequent work continuing to read it with pleasure.
—James

download or read online

Read Online

Write Review

(Review will shown on site after approval)

Other books by author Philip Kerr

Other books in category Horror