Share for friends:

A Place Of Safety (2001)

A Place Of Safety (2001)

Book Info

Genre
Rating
3.82 of 5 Votes: 5
Your rating
ISBN
0312977107 (ISBN13: 9780312977108)
Language
English
Publisher
st. martin's paperbacks

About book A Place Of Safety (2001)

A girl falls into a river and appears to drown. An unpleasant man is out walking his dog at night and is discovered next morning dead and his dog seriously injured. Someone is being blackmailed and others are engaged in activities which may or may not result in harm to them or others. Tom Barnaby and his wife, Joyce, are about to celebrate their silver wedding anniversary – can they actually manage to have a celebratory meal with their daughter and son-in-law without crime getting in the way?In spite of the promising ingredients this book did not hold my attention in the same way others in the series have done. I liked the characters and thought the nasty ones were particularly obnoxious but there seemed to be something lacking in this complex story and the way the solution was revealed. It could be that as I have read the series virtually back to back that boredom is setting in – I am not sure. The book is well written but I felt the plot was a little too complex and it would have been fairly difficult for the reader to work out who was the murderer. On sheer character alone it was possible to see who the most likely suspect was but it didn’t seem that this person could be responsible.In spite of those criticisms I did enjoy the book – just not as much as I have enjoyed the rest of the series so far. Barnaby and Troy are still good value as characters and the village setting was well done but there was just something lacking to my mind – though others may love this book.

After enjoying The killings at Badgers Drift and Written in blood, especially the latter, I was looking forward to reading this, but it did not get live up to expectations. The opening 50-100 pages or so were good but then after that I found it quite dull. It never gripped me or drew me in and I didn't find any of the characters very interesting, they were a bit too whimsical. I personally think Caroline Graham used too much description and it often seemed to take a while to get to the point. It felt like a short story or novella that was enlarged into a 342 page long book, when 100 pages would have more than sufficed. I were to say something positive about it, it did have a good beginning, it's just a shame It didn't keep up. I would not recommend this book, but I would definitely recommend the two books mentioned at the beginning by the same author as they were very good. Every author should be allowed one bad book, this was Caroline Graham's.

Do You like book A Place Of Safety (2001)?

Basis of BBC-TV Midsomer Murders, pattern unfolds similarly, following Inspector Barnaby's family life, here silver wedding anniversary celebrated with his daughter Cully and her actor husband. Relationship chains have optimistic endings - men, family, animals, yield and usurp power. Vacation feel from Brit slang and expressions like "dot carry one" for limping/ lame, and "Anglepoise" for a swivel arm task lamp (banned by a BBC head who thought small lights bred dark subversive thoughts - is that why a miners' strike crippled the country?). Readers meet local eccentrics, pampered pets, experience minutiae of village life, look inside heads - unappreciated Sergeant, relieved widow, too-caring sister, spoiled canine. What starts as a bully's typical nightly dog walk degenerates into disaster. A girl disappears into a river, blackmail ensues, then murder, almost-murder, accidental murder provoked by icky perverted obsession and a hint of child abuse from a questionable source, the last two not general prime-time fare. "All my life. Off and on." is a deceptive reply, unfair to a reader trying to sort out the loving connection between young girl and boy. Surprises, twists, bad people mean no place is safe, even a victim can become a criminal. (view spoiler)[ Infatuated pansy grapples dominant partner at fatal height. (hide spoiler)]
—An Odd1

Caroline Graham has one of her characters describe Inspector Barnaby as, "a man unclouded by sentiment but not without kindness." I think her writing could be described the same way. We see the characters and get to know them. We may like them or not. We may have sympathy for them or want to see the perpetrators apprehended but either way the author does not beat us over the head with a certain point of view. We are left to form our own opinions. I particularly enjoyed this book because I hadn't seen the movie. I'm not even sure this one was done as a movie, if so I missed it. I think this allowed me to form my own ideas about the characters and where things were headed. Some things here I got right away but others eluded me to the end. As in any really great mystery even the things I didn't get I could go back and see that the information was all there if I had only been able to put it together in the right way. This was one of my favorite Inspector Barnaby mysteries.
—Sharla

A couple of summers ago I got hooked on an English tv mystery series loosely based on the character of Chief Inspector Barnaby created by Carolyn Graham. I decided to read a couple of her books because I enjoyed the bbc series so much. There are several novels with inspector Barnaby as the lead character, the plots are somewhat predictable but fun to read, particularly if you like the mystery genre...which I do. I thought that the T.V. script writers did a good of a job with refining and fleshing out the char acts, plots and setting that ms. Graham initiated, so I know that this is goodreads, but Midsomer Murders headed up by Inspector Barnaby is a goodwatch if you are in need of a marathon tv series to recuperate from surgery or life.
—Cindy

download or read online

Read Online

Write Review

(Review will shown on site after approval)

Other books by author Caroline Graham

Other books in series chief inspector barnaby

Other books in category Fiction