Share for friends:

East To The Dawn: The Life Of Amelia Earhart (1997)

East To The Dawn: The Life Of Amelia Earhart (1997)

Book Info

Author
Rating
3.8 of 5 Votes: 5
Your rating
ISBN
0201311445 (ISBN13: 9780201311440)
Language
English
Publisher
da capo press

About book East To The Dawn: The Life Of Amelia Earhart (1997)

As others who have reviewed this book have noted, this is the definitive, best-researched book on Amelia Earhart's life that has been published to date. What's interesting to me is that all of the reviewers go on, after stating this fact, to give glowing reviews to Earhart's life, and translate that to the book itself. While Earhart's life and personality are fascinating, the style of this book is tedious, and reading it was drudgery interspersed with a few surprising tidbits. I only forced myself to finish the book because a)it was a gift; b)I've been interested in Amelia Earhart since childhood; and c) I thought I should finish it so I could give it a complete review.My two main complaints are style and context. It's clear that this book took 10 years to research. In fact, there are points in the book where the text reads like a list of facts that are strung together without anything connecting them. In other places, there are several instances where the author repeats the same descriptive phrase twice in the same paragraph. This happened several times in relation to new characters who were being introduced. This is unsettling as a reader because it makes the prose repetitive, and you wonder if the author thought you might not be paying attention, or if the author herself wasn't paying attention when she was writing. In addition, much of Butler's commentary is trite, and her style lacks consistency and the ability to engage the reader.In terms of context, the author went too far in creating the context of Amelia's life. The first 100 pages or so chronicle Amelia's first 20 years and the history of her ancestors, 3 generations back. Those 100 pages felt like 400, and it was a tough slog through this opening section. Lots of unnecessary detail, and a long list of characters detracted from the main objective of setting the context of Amelia's family and upbringing. Further on in the book, the author continues to deviate from her main point to include random facts and relationships. While some of this can be acceptable to help the reader better understand the era in which Earhart lived, it was largely distracting and the author often wandered for paragraphs or pages at a time.In short, Susan Butler did a very thorough job researching Amelia Earhart's life. I only wish that she had such a thorough editor who would've helped her condense her immense body of research into a clear, articulate and engaging biography.

I only finished reading this book because I knew so little about Amelia Earhart before I started reading it - namely the fatal attempt to circumnavigate the world - that learning anything would be a bonus. I feel like I learned about her in spite of the author's best intentions. When the author wasn't be repetitive she was being contradictory. Chronology and logic had no room in this book, characters and events were mentioned, discarded and then brought back out of context many chapters later. Twice she referred to her Pacific flight as an example of the challenges Earhart had overcome in comparison to the societal pressures she was facing, yet hadn't even described the flight yet. She seemed obsessed with Earhart's financial situation even if she continually flip-flopped on it: she first mentioned how poor her childhood had been, but when then later describing her childhood mentioned they had their own train car provided by her father's job. She was constantly struggling with poverty yet could buy a car and a plane. In the span of a half a page the author said both that Earhart was making enough to have paid off her debts and that she was still $1,000 in debt. So which one is it?The people are as flat as the story. I feel like I learned nothing about who Earhart and the people in her life really were. She was engaged to one person, married to another, and carrying on at least one affair (and possibly more) but we never learn much about any of these people. There is as much time spent describing her grandparents and ancestors as there is her fatal expedition. Earhart was so much more than just a pilot - social worker, feminist, educator - that it would be a tragedy if there isn't a much better biography out there.

Do You like book East To The Dawn: The Life Of Amelia Earhart (1997)?

In the late twenties and the 1930s, Amelia Earhart was one of America's heroes--America's heroine, as Butler reminds us was the terminology at the time, when gendered terms were still regarded as the norm rather than a bit weird. What's left to us now is an image of Earhart just out of the cockpit, or about to step into it, and the memory of her disappearance on her around-the-world flight.But Earhart was much, much more than one image and one heartbreaking last flight. She was far more even than "just" a daredevil pilot in the years when aviation was establishing itself and just beginning to be commercially viable.Butler digs into Earhart's background, her family background as well as her challenges and achievements before that last, iconic, and tragically ended round-the-world flight.From her early life sent to live the winter months with her lonely grandmother in Atchison, Kansas, to the increasingly strained years with her parents and sister as her father drank and her parents' marriage deteriorated, she was the bright, adventurous light. She was also often the practical and responsible anchor in the strained family home, sacrificing many of her own opportunities to take care of her mother and sister. Yet along with pursuing a higher education despite the financial constraints, she also began flying early. Her parents had reconciled and her father moved them out to California, and Amelia Earhart discovered flying.What surprised me is that, after a number of bumps and challenges along the way, the career she established herself in was social work, and the city she did it in was Boston. Who saw that coming? I didn't! How she got from Miss Earhart of the Boston settlement house Dennison House, to Amelia Earhart, first woman to cross the Atlantic in an airplane, makes a fascinating story. From there, we embark on her other adventures, and on the equally public writing, public relations, and teaching that, for her, for the flyer who said she still considered herself a social worker, were an integral part of what she was doing.The real revelation, for me, is how involved she was in the early development of commercial aviation.Of course, we all know the ending, the flight from which she did not make it home. Even there, though, I learned quite a bit.Recommended.
—Lis Carey

Susan Butler's "East to the Dawn: the life of Amelia Earhart," is hands-down the best book I have read about Amelia Earhart. It was meticulously researched (it took her 10 years to research and write the book, and it shows) and also included insights into the life of this early 20th Century feminist that could only have been provided by a woman author. In much the same way that Doris Goodwin Kearns brought a woman's insight into the White House life of Eleanor and Franklin Roosevelt in "No Ordinary Time," Susan Butler does in writing about Amelia Earhart. Amelia's contributions to and hopes for women were far more fully described in this book than in the three others I have also read about her.Susan Butler also doesn't try to hide Amelia's blemishes, nor does she overstate the overbearing personality of George Putnam, her husband. She gives a very balanced account of their life together, which was sometimes rocky.Another very nice aspect of the book was the inclusion of some research not found or not described in the other biographies of Amelia, including some correspondence between Fred Noonan (her navigator on the last flight) and a female friend of his, whom Amelia and Fred visited on their stay in Miami, their last U.S. stop-over on the final flight. This correspondence sheds new light and casts additional uncertainty about Fred's problems with alcohol as a potential reason for their failure on the last leg of their round the world flight on which they disappeared, 70 years ago this month.The inclusion of materials on Gene Vidal (Gore's father), who served as Secretary to Commerce for Aviation Affairs during the FDR administration, was also extremely interesting and contributed to a fuller understanding of the work involved in preparing for the Final Flight. Amelia's relationship with Gene was also the human element that I usually find extremely interesting in non-fiction and biographical books.If Amelia interests you at all and you are only going to read one book about her, make this the one.
—Brian

An excellent updated biography of Earhart that adds family letters and diaries to the historical record. Butler describes the personality of Earhart in her own words, using quotes from those who knew her to make an author's judgment from among conflicting descriptions. Earhart was a meticulous planner and experienced pilot, who nonetheless has personality quirks of her own. The book also has the best description that I've seen of her involvement with Purdue University and the Purdue Research Foundation in teaching -- and funding the Lockheed Electra that she used for her final voyage.Butler also describes the final flight around the world using documents from Earhart's husband and others involved first-hand, dismissing stories of Japanese captivity and dwelling on likely equipment failures. She leaves the mystery of Fred Noonan (was he extremely competent or was he drunk?) unanswered. All in all, a well-told story from childhood through Earhart's disappearance over the Pacific Ocean. And it is done in a manner to be inspirational to any youngster facing the obstacles of their upbringing.
—Andrew

download or read online

Read Online

Write Review

(Review will shown on site after approval)

Other books in category Graphic Novels & Comics