Share for friends:

The Colossus Of New York (2004)

The Colossus of New York (2004)

Book Info

Genre
Rating
3.63 of 5 Votes: 5
Your rating
ISBN
1400031249 (ISBN13: 9781400031245)
Language
English
Publisher
anchor

About book The Colossus Of New York (2004)

"Talking about New York City is a way of talking about the world."If I was born/raised/living in NYC, I probably would be giving this a four- or five-star review. It's uniquely written—a book split up into short chapters on different locations and things that make up the city (JFK, Rain, Port Authority, Rush Hour, Brooklyn Bridge, etc.)—and has succinct but beautifully descriptive moments. I thought I could dig into it even though NYC is not technically part of my makeup, but unfortunately I found myself getting really restless halfway through. I almost never give up on books, but I skimmed like shit through the final third of this one.The beginning started off with a bang though. Some quotes I love:"You start building your own private New York the first time you lay eyes on it. Maybe you were in a cab leaving the airport when the skyline first roused itself into view. All your worldly possessions were in the trunk, and in your hand you held an address on a piece of paper. Look: that's the Empire State Building, over there are the Twin Towers. Somewhere in that fantastic, glorious mess was the address on the piece of paper, your first home here. Maybe your parents first dragged you here for a vacation when you were a kid and towed you up and down the gigantic avenues to shop for Christmas gifts. [...] Maybe you came to visit your old buddy, the one who moved here last summer, and there was some mix-up as to where you were supposed to meet. You stepped out of Penn Station into the dizzying hustle of Eighth Avenue and fainted. Freeze it there: that instant is the first brick in your city.""The city knows you better than any living person because it has seen you when you are alone. It saw you steeling yourself for the job interview, slowly walking home after the late date, tripping over nonexistent impediments on the sidewalk. [...] It saw you half-running up the street after you got the keys to your first apartment. The city saw all that. Remembers, too.""Consider what all your old apartments would say if they got together to swap stories. They could piece together the starts and finishes of your relationships, complain about your wardrobe and musical tastes, gossip about who you are after midnight. [...] Cherish your old apartments and pause for a moment when you pass them. Pay tribute, for they are the caretakers of your reinventions."

Dazzling? Entrancing? Really?!! I must respectfully disagree. Yes, there are lines and comments that are beautiful and interesting, but for the most part it reminds me of the free-form poetry bs that literary types have foisted on readers, snickering as the accept accolades from friends and supporters, while most readers just think, "wtf?" Same group that tries to pass off the bulk of modern art as "genius" while denigrating other artistic genres. As poetry, this cobbled collection of concepts would be okay, but he decided to deliver it narratively, resulting in a choppy mixture of description, cliché, and commentary. Yes, it does deliver some insight into New York, but many passages are applicable to almost anyone living in a city anywhere, as they confront reality and memory. I think he gets quite a lot right in his observations, and not a few times I felt I would have the same feelings, and have in fact. There is a lot to like here, but this work can also be irritating and frustrating, and frankly I wouldn't recommend it to most people. He is a celebrated writer, so I hope his other stuff is more compelling. To me this felt like an "I've gotta deliver something to the publisher" in between more-traditional efforts.

Do You like book The Colossus Of New York (2004)?

A hard read, but worth it... This is an odd book. It's written in some kind of peculiar free-form writing style, with different sentences in the same paragraph switching from first person to third person, and just to confuse further switches fluidly from one person ("he") to another ("she") but you are either he or she, depending on whether... you know. Anyway, writing style aside, this is an interesting essay on life in modern-day New York. I read this on holiday in New York, and finished it when I'd got back home. The second half was much more fun - perhaps because I'd got to know NYC by then, so appreciated some of the little clever things in the book. So - good if you know NYC, though a little hard-going. Keep your wits about you when reading.
—James Cridland

Wow.I'd had this sitting on my shelf for five years or so, waiting to be read. I'm glad I finally pulled my finger out and gave it a whirl; Whitehead has managed to bottle the Big Apple in this slim volume. Other reviewers give him crap for being a peacock - preening and artificial. But I think this misreads his intentions. I thought it more a reflection of the city itself - loud, self-inventing, chopping, changing, never quite staying the same. It feels more Beat-like than some of the Beats (a bunch I'm not terribly in love with, I must say) but hums along with that sort of highly caffeinated energy that NY does so well.Some of these stories, I must admit, are less about New York in particular and more about the minutiae of living in a big city. No matter where you live, you'll recognise the rainy day scurry, the inner voice chatting on public transport, the personal mapping of environment by landmarks that have changed name, or gone completely. So in that respect it's not -strictly- a NYC work. But hell, it made me want to go back, so it has to have some strange power of the land of yellow cabs inside it, right?It's short and sweet - there's something transient in the work, like a lost weekend in town. I found myself wanting to read particular passages to my partner, wanting to push it onto other likeminded people and say "See, you would dig this!" - that desire to spread the word is well-earned. Whitehead's prose sounds like the city, with all its bustle, flatulence and come-on. A wonderful read. If you've ever been there or ever wanted to go, this is for you.
—Luke

Colson Whitehead delivers yet another course in strong writing. The Colossus of New York is a love letter to New York city. Whitehead captures the ebb, flow, and character of JFK, rain in the city, and Times Square. The collection - a series of short pieces linked by gymnasticaly clever language and topic, to form a pre-twitter, twitter-styled novella. Though less fluid than the other writing I've read by Whitehead - the clipped sentences, point of view changes, and clever language, all together, can be at first disorienting, the book remains a delight. I appreciate Whitehead's creativity - and of course, his hallmark skills with language and uncannily perceptive insight, are again on display - and here, as in other works, it results in some truly poetic phrasing and sharp observations. As when he desribes everyone's favorite city dweller: the hipster."Hipsters seek refuge in church, Our Lady of Perpetual Subculture. There is some discussion as to whether or not they are still cool but then they are calmed by the obscure location and the arrival of their kind. Keep the address to yourself, let the rabble find it for themselves. Wow, this crappy performance art is really aking me feel not so terrible about my various emotional issues."Whitehead evocatively draws the city - and the special nuances of city life. The possessiveness, routines that declare belonging, and the humor in being shoved so close to one another, and yet busy with our own "rich interior lives."Each time I read something by Whitehead, I feel lucky to have found out about him.
—Izetta Autumn

download or read online

Read Online

Write Review

(Review will shown on site after approval)

Other books by author Colson Whitehead

Other books in category Fiction